Troubleshoot & restore

If your cast iron looks a bit worn, it's easy to put right. Here's how.
How to fix common problems with your cast iron pan
Cast iron is tough, but now and then small things come up. Nothing to worry about. Here's how to get your pan back in good shape.
Rust
Orange or reddish spots mean moisture has got in.
What to do:
- Scrub with steel wool or a brush until the rust is gone.
- Rinse, dry thoroughly and oil lightly.
- Re-season in the oven for extra protection.
Black flakes
This means parts of the seasoning have come loose. It's usually from oil layers that were too thick and never hardened properly.
What to do:
- Scrub off loose flakes with a brush or sponge.
- Wash, dry and do a new, thin seasoning in the oven.
Brown surface or uneven colour
A dull brown or patchy surface is common, especially at first. It's part of the pan settling in.
What to do:
- Use the pan regularly and it will even out.
- Want to speed things up? Season it again.
Odd smell
If the pan smells of old fat or stale air, oil residue has gone rancid, often after the pan has been left unused.
What to do:
- Heat the empty pan over medium heat to burn off the residue.
- Wash, dry and oil lightly.
- Store it somewhere dry and airy, without the lid on.
Surface that feels rough or is coming off
The seasoning may not have built up properly yet, or food has stuck hard.
What to do:
- Use your pan often. Every time you cook, the surface gets stronger.
- Rinse it straight after use, dry and oil it.
- Still too rough? Season it again.
Patchy colour: grey, black and brown
Completely normal. Every time you use the pan, it builds on its own patina.
What to do:
- Keep using it. The colour evens out over time.
- If you like, even it out with a new seasoning.
Black marks on the paper
What it is:
It can be worrying to wipe the pan and see black marks on the kitchen paper, but it's completely normal, especially on new pans. What you're seeing is small residue from the seasoning: polymerised oil that hasn't fully bonded yet, or is left over after cooking.
What to do:
- Keep using the pan as normal. Each time you cook, the surface hardens and less comes off.
- Want the marks gone sooner? Put the pan in the oven at 250 °C for 30–60 minutes without new oil. That helps set the surface.
- Once the pan has cooled, wipe it with fresh kitchen paper. If it comes away clean, you're done.
Tip:
A few black marks just mean the seasoning is still settling in.
Sticky surface after seasoning
What it is:
A sticky or slightly oily surface after seasoning is a clear sign that too much oil was used, or that the pan didn't get hot enough for the oil to harden completely. It can also happen if the oil wasn't spread in an even, thin layer, which is what gives an even, hard surface.
What to do:
1. Heat the pan in the oven at 200–250 °C for about 60 minutes, without adding new oil. That burns off the excess.
2. Let it cool in the oven. Feel the surface. Is it less sticky?
3. If it still feels greasy, wash it with hot water and a drop of washing-up liquid, dry thoroughly, and start again with a very thin layer of oil and a new seasoning.
Tip:
When seasoning, think "almost invisible layer". If it shines, it's probably too much. Three thin layers are better than one thick one.
Remember: It's almost impossible to ruin a cast iron pan. You can rescue it, clean it and season it again, as many times as you need.

